Separation. Divorce. Nullity. Dissolution. Redress Scheme. What’s the difference?

So, what is the difference between Separation, Divorce,. Nullity, Dissolution and the Redress Scheme?

If you and your spouse have decided to end your relationship there are options for every type of long-term relationship. Here is an outline of 7 different types of separation for those who are married or in a long-term civil relationship.

1️⃣ Separation Agreement:

If you have both agreed on the broad terms of your separation either through mediation or mutual discussion, it’s important to note that this is ‼️NOT a legally binding agreement. However, a solicitor can legally incorporate your separation terms into a legally binding agreement called a Deed of Separation or a Separation Agreement, this is a legally binding contract between a married couple or civil partners who choose to live apart without immediately divorcing. This agreement outlines key aspects like the division of assets, maintenance payments, child custody arrangements, and living arrangements. While it is not a court order and does not allow remarriage, a well-drafted Separation Agreement, typically created with legal assistance from a solicitor or mediator, enables the couple to live independently while still legally married. It can also serve as a foundation for future divorce or dissolution.

2️⃣ Judicial Separation:

In brief, a Judicial separation is when the Court formally declares that you and your spouse are no longer legally obliged to live together and The Court decides on the terms of your separation. In Irish law, this is a formal court order declaring that you and your spouse are no longer legally required to cohabitate. The Court makes the legally binding decisions on the terms of your separation, including financial arrangements, property division and child custody if necessary.

3️⃣ Divorce:

If you and your spouse decide to separate and proceed with a divorce, court proceedings must be issued whether your application is contentious or straightforward. It’s not possible to obtain a divorce without a Judge formally granting the decree. 
Divorce in Ireland legally ends a marriage, which then allows remarriage. To divorce, couples must have lived apart for at least two years, show no chance of reconciliation, and provide for all parties involved. The process starts with an application to the Circuit Court (or High Court for significant assets), requiring a Family Law Civil Bill, an Affidavit of Means, and an Affidavit of Welfare for children. The court considers the welfare of children, financial circumstances, and accommodation needs when making decisions about maintenance, property, and custody.

4️⃣ Civil Nullity Decree:

A court declaration stating that, although two individuals underwent a marriage ceremony, their marriage never existed in the eyes of the state due to specific legal reasons. ⚠️ Applications for church annulment is an entirely separate matter.
A civil nullity decree in Ireland is a legal declaration by the High Court that a marriage was never valid due to fundamental defects at the time of the ceremony. It’s different from divorce, as it states that no valid marriage existed. Reasons for nullity include lack of capacity to marry, failure to meet legal formalities, or absence of genuine consent. If granted, it means the parties were never married and can remarry without needing a divorce.

5️⃣ Nullity:

For civil partnerships, a court may also declare this partnership null and void, meaning that despite having a ceremony, no valid civil partnership exists. In a legal context, Nullity is a court declaration that a seemingly valid act, like a marriage or contract, was flawed from the beginning and has no legal effect. Unlike dissolution, which ends a valid arrangement, nullity asserts that the act never existed legally. In Ireland, a decree of nullity from the High Court means that due to certain legal defects at the time of marriage, a valid union was never formed, allowing the parties to be considered legally single.

6️⃣ Dissolution:

Civil Partners must wait at least two years before making an application for Dissolution, so it’s a sensible option to enter into a Separation Agreement pending Dissolution. In Irish law, “dissolution” refers to the legal termination of a civil partnership, which is similar to divorce. It thus allows former partners to enter new civil partnerships or marriages. To obtain a dissolution decree, the couple must have lived apart for at least two of the last three years, and the court must ensure proper provisions for both partners and any dependent children. The process is similar to divorce, involving court applications and considerations of financial arrangements, property division, and children’s welfare.

7️⃣ The Redress Scheme:

Supports those considered “Qualifying Cohabitants.” If you lived with your partner for at least two years with children or five years without, and your relationship has ended, you may be eligible to claim compensatory maintenance if you are financially dependent.

Navigating the complex and emotionally charged area of family law can be overwhelming, particularly when separation or divorce is involved.If you need professional guidance, Our legal team at Synnott Lawline Family Law is here to answer any questions you may have. We offer practical advice, peace of mind, and timely resolutions for various situations, including Judicial Separation, divorce, Civil Nullity, Cohabitation Agreements, Separation Agreements for Civil Partners, and any legal issues affecting children. Our goal is to negotiate amicable settlements while avoiding unnecessary adversarial litigation. 

Contact us today – we are here to help! email our specialised family lawyer Aimee at info@lawline or call 014537890

*General Practice Law Terms and Conditions: A consultation with a solicitor must be prepaid in advance of a phone or office consultation. To book the appointment contact us by phone 014537890, email info@lawline.ie or fill out our contact form and we will contact you to confirm your time, date and arrange payment method.